Mediation
Diary/Planner
Simplified Divorce
Divorce Details

Divorce Details

Divorce in Scotland

In Scotland there are five grounds upon which to base an action of divorce: adultery, desertion, unreasonable behaviour, separation for two years with the consent of both partners and separation for five years without the consent of the other party.

Where the parties relationship has broken down then that in itself will usually constitute grounds for divorce. A good Solicitor should be able to identify the necessary grounds for divorce and frame an application in such a way as to be sufficient for the Courts purposes to enable divorce to be granted.

The five grounds are summarised below.

Adultery

This is not ground that lawyers often need to explain to clients. 

This is defined as voluntary sexual intercourse between a married person and a person of the opposite sex. This definition obviously excludes non-consensual intercourse. Also it is important to note that it is only intercourse which will be sufficient. Other forms of sexual activity which do not amount to intercourse may be sufficient to establish the irretrievable breakdown by a spouse’s behaviour (see later).

Most Divorce lawyers will tell you that the most frequently encountered difficulty in an adultery case is proof. Where there is an illegitimate child or the guilty parties are prepared to admit that intercourse has taken place the problem does not arise however in many cases this sort of evidence is not available. In the majority of cases there will merely be a suspicion albeit a well held one. Diary entries, love letters, greetings cards, and "opportunity" can all be used but more often than not private investigators are brought in and this can be expensive.

Desertion

The desertion of a spouse involves leaving your partner for no good reason for a period of two years. This can include living under the same roof but living quite separate lives.

For all practical purposes desertion rarely occurs and most people leave their partners for very good reasons. In a way this ground is detached from everyday life and one wonders at its purpose.

This ground is rarely used in support of a divorce application. Many experienced family lawyers will tell you they have never been involved with a desertion action. As with adultery the Scottish executive quite propose to replace this ground with a generalised, unreasonable behaviour category.

Unreasonable behaviour

The Divorce (Scotland) Act does not specifically use the term unreasonable behaviour. In actual fact it is the expectation that a spouse can live with his her partner which must be unreasonable rather than the behaviour itself. The court will be satisfied on this ground if the defender’s behaviour is such that it is not reasonable for the particular applicant spouse to be expected to live with him or her. In this way Scottish law takes into account the applicants own character and personality and what may be reasonable for one pursuer may not be reasonable for another.

The kind of behaviour envisaged by the legislation and case law is almost unlimited and extends from deliberate acts of cruelty ( mental or otherwise )through to the symptoms of a mental illness provided that this involves some form of behaviour.

This is the most common ground of divorce as it reflects most people's experience of an unhappy marriage and does not require lengthy periods of living apart before you can go to court.

Two years Separation with Consent 

Where parties have lived apart for two years or more, one of the parties can raise an action of divorce with the consent of the other party. (Sometimes referred to as Simplified Divorce Procedure)

This is an example of a no fault divorce. It is a ground which is commonly used especially where the parties have resolved their personal difficulties and agreed to an amicable separation.

Five years separation

This ground is self explanatory. The defender is not required to consent. In practice most people who contemplate a divorce have got round to it well before the fifth anniversary of their separation. However there are occasions where this may be the only ground open to a spouse. Although the defenders consent is not required the proceedings are intimated to him or her. Defenders in this sort of action are few and far between as the net effect of a successful defence is of course that the parties are still married and after a period of five years separate.

Simplified Divorce

An application can be made to your local Sheriff Court for a simple divorce on the last two grounds only on the basis that there are no money issues between the parties and no children under the age of sixteen.

The cost of such a divorce is £56 and there is generally no requirement for a solicitor to become involved except to notarise the form.

If you are on Income support the Court or your Solicitor will provide a form which will exempt you from the £56 fee.

There is no need to attend a Court hearing and a divorce can usually be completed in seven or eight weeks.

You can apply for divorce using the simplified divorce procedure at this web site. This service is not available anywhere else and will save you hundreds of pounds in Solicitor fees.

Normal Divorce Proceeding's

Divorces can only be raised in the Sheriff Court or the Court of Session. It is considerably more economic to raise an action in the Sheriff Court.

While it is possible to raise your own divorce proceeding's it is advisable to employ a Solicitor. Divorce law is now technical and complex and where contentious issues arise about finances or children then you almost always require legal assistance.

Legal Aid is available but restricted to parties on benefits and very low incomes.

Interim Orders

Where issues of urgency arise the Court can make interim orders. These include orders regulating both the care of children and ailment for a spouse. Other orders which can be dealt with very quickly include interdicts and exclusion orders where violence is an issue. For more information see the sections on Children, financial orders and matrimonial Interdicts. In general the Courts no longer deal with child support. This is now the exclusive remit of the Child Support Agency.

Only when all the financial aspects of divorce and the care of any children have been resolved can the Courts in Scotland grant a divorce.

Final Orders on Divorce

The range of orders possible on divorce are effectively unlimited but in general regulate two matters: the children and the financial status of the parties to the marriage.

Upon divorce each party is no longer entitled to ailment each other. This obligation may however be continued for a short time after marriage where the court makes an order for periodic allowance to enable a party to adjust to new financial circumstances.

Orders relating to who will have care and control of the children and who can have contact to the children can be made. The courts will not make an order relating to the care of the children unless necessary. If the children's care has been arranged satisfactorily between the parties no order will be made.

An order may be made for the sale of the matrimonial home or the transfer of tenancy of the home.

All aspects of the families finances can be regulated including the apportionment of property including the pension(s), shares, deposits and other assets. The most usual way of dealing with this is by an order for a capital sum to be made to be paid to one of the spouses.

A deferred order for a capital payment is often considered where the assets are tied up in a pension scheme. The court can 'earmark' pension funds which must be paid out when the pension matures. This prevents the pension holder obtaining his lump sum and not paying some of it over to his ex spouse.

Where there has been violence interdicts can be granted for indefinite periods. unfortunately other orders such as power of arrest are not possible after divorce. This is being reviewed by the Executive.

Effect of a Divorce

A divorce means that the legal relationship between the parties has come to an end. The only shared obligation the parties generally have after divorce will be to the children. All rights in property or for inheritance purposes are dissolved by a divorce. Ex-spouses are single and entitled to remarry. In the law's eyes, the parties are now entitled to go their own ways and their obligations to each other are at an end.

Reform

The general concept of proving fault in divorce proceeding's often results in aggravating the already difficult relationship between separating spouses. This is to nobodies benefit and often results in greater acrimony which can effect both the parties themselves and the children.

We are of a view that the simple concept of irretrievable breakdown should be adopted. This could be simply constituted by a period of separation. The fault grounds of divorce should be repealed.

Unfortunately reform of the divorce laws can result in very powerful interest groups becoming involved. This often slows the process of reform. The divorce laws in Scotland date back to the late nineteen sixties. Much has changed in society since then.

Marriage is considered, rightly, as one of the mainstay's of society and it is often argued that divorce is too easily obtained. It is true that divorces can be simply acquired but we would argue that this is the Court recognizing the right to live your life as you wish within the law.

The European Convention on Human Rights recognizes the right to a family life but this includes the right to move on and establish new family relationships. Unfortunately the divorce laws, by pitting spouses against each other, don't help people move on and by so doing retard the healing process. Divorce is traumatic and often divisive and the adversarial court system we have in Scotland often only makes this worse.

On the 20th of January 2000, Jim Wallace, the Justice Minister announced his intention to review divorce law. This included reducing the time you needed to be apart to divorce to one year with consent and two without. He also suggested scrapping divorce on the grounds of adultery and desertion and having an all encompassing category of unreasonable behaviour.

It is unlikely that these proposals will become law before two years are past.

 

Back Up Back ] [ Up ]

scottishfamilylaw.com © 2004
Design by traklaw.com

Home
FAQs
How to Contact Us