The general concept of proving fault in divorce
proceeding's often results in aggravating the already
difficult relationship between separating spouses. This is to
nobodies benefit and often results in greater acrimony which
can effect both the parties themselves and the children.
We are of a view that the simple concept of irretrievable
breakdown should be adopted. This could be simply constituted
by a period of separation. The fault grounds of divorce should
be repealed.
Unfortunately reform of the divorce laws can result in very
powerful interest groups becoming involved. This often slows
the process of reform. The divorce laws in Scotland date back
to the late nineteen sixties. Much has changed in society
since then.
Marriage is considered, rightly, as one of the mainstay's
of society and it is often argued that divorce is too easily
obtained. It is true that divorces can be simply acquired but
we would argue that this is the Court recognizing the right to
live your life as you wish within the law.
The European Convention on Human Rights recognizes the
right to a family life but this includes the right to move on
and establish new family relationships. Unfortunately the
divorce laws, by pitting spouses against each other, don't
help people move on and by so doing retard the healing
process. Divorce is traumatic and often divisive and the
adversarial court system we have in Scotland often only makes
this worse.
On the 20th of January 2000, Jim Wallace, the Justice
Minister announced his intention to review divorce law. This
included reducing the time you needed to be apart to divorce
to one year with consent and two without. He also suggested
scrapping divorce on the grounds of adultery and desertion and
having an all encompassing category of unreasonable behaviour.
It is unlikely that these proposals will become law before
two years are past.